The Power of Hope in Leadership: A Transactional Analysis Perspective

Hope is not just an emotion; it is a fundamental necessity in leadership. Recent research underscores that among the core needs of followers, hope emerges as the most vital component. Gallup’s Global Leadership Report highlights that 56% of leadership attributes associated with positive influence relate to hope. Similarly, Scientific American emphasises that hope has a more profound impact than even mindfulness in fostering resilience and engagement.

In this context, Eric Berne’s Transactional Analysis (TA) offers a valuable lens through which leaders can provide hope using ego states—particularly the Critical Parent, Nurturing Parent, and Adult ego states.

The Role of Hope in Leadership

Gallup’s research identifies four key needs that followers seek from their leaders: hope, trust, compassion, and stability. Among these, hope stands out as the foundation for trust, engagement, and future-orientated action. Leaders who instill hope create environments where employees feel motivated and connected to a vision greater than themselves. Without hope, employees may become disengaged, cynical, and uncertain about the future, leading to diminished performance and well-being.

Scientific American further supports this notion, asserting that hope fosters proactive behaviours, problem-solving, and resilience in times of uncertainty. It is not just wishful thinking but an actionable belief that the future can improve and that individuals have the agency to influence outcomes.

A study from Clemson University and North Carolina State University, in collaboration with MusiCares, found that musicians and performers who maintained hope during the COVID-19 pandemic displayed greater resilience, emotional well-being, and adaptability in the face of adversity.

Transactional Analysis and Hope-Driven Leadership

Eric Berne’s Transactional Analysis describes three primary ego states: the Parent, the Adult, and the Child. Within the Parent ego state, the Critical Parent and Nurturing Parent play crucial roles in shaping how leaders communicate hope.

The Critical Parent as a Containing Force

The Critical Parent is often seen as a disciplinarian, setting boundaries and ensuring accountability. While it may be perceived negatively, it provides structure and stability, essential for employees seeking direction and certainty.

Effective leaders in this state:

• Instil confidence by demonstrating strategic foresight and resilience.

• Offer clear expectations to help employees feel secure and hopeful about the future.

• Reinforce structured vision with measured guidance, helping teams navigate challenges effectively.

The Nurturing Parent as an Encouraging Force

The Nurturing Parent provides emotional support, fostering psychological safety and trust. Leaders in this state:

• Reassure employees during crises, ensuring emotional stability.

• Acknowledge efforts and reinforce self-belief in employees.

• Align with Gallup’s findings, emphasising that trust and compassion are integral to effective leadership.

The Adult Ego State as a Rational Balancer

The Adult ego state processes information logically, making balanced decisions based on facts rather than emotions.

When leaders operate from this state:

• They assess reality accurately while fostering realistic optimism.

• Provide measured motivation with credible strategic direction.

• Offer tangible solutions based on clear evidence to help employees remain hopeful and engaged.

Practical Strategies for Hope-Based Leadership

Given the significance of hope, leaders must intentionally cultivate it within their teams.

1. Balance the Critical and Nurturing Parent States

• Set firm but fair expectations (Critical Parent) while also offering encouragement and empathy (Nurturing Parent).

2. Use the Adult State to Communicate Realistic Optimism

• Avoid false hope by using data, strategy, and thoughtful planning to provide a credible vision for the future.

3. Foster Psychological Safety

• Create environments where employees feel safe to express concerns, ask questions, and receive honest feedback.

• Strengthen resilience and trust in leadership by maintaining transparency.

4. Encourage Future-Oriented Thinking

• Hopefulness is a future-orientated state, helping people generate pathways around challenges.

• Leaders can cultivate this mindset by encouraging employees to visualise goals, strategise solutions, and take proactive steps toward success.

Leadership as a ‘Dealer in Hope’

Napoleon Bonaparte famously said, “A leader is a dealer in hope.” Today’s research and psychological insights affirm this wisdom.

Leaders who provide hope through:

• Clear vision and strategic guidance.

• Emotional support and psychological safety.

• Rational decision-making and logical leadership.

Create the conditions for trust, engagement, and long-term success.

By leveraging Transactional Analysis, leaders can understand the interplay between their ego states and consciously adopt behaviours that instill hope in their teams.

Conclusion: The Cornerstone of Effective Leadership

In an era of uncertainty, hope is not just an abstract ideal—it is the cornerstone of effective leadership.

Transactional Analysis forms the foundation of the Circle & Square leadership framework. To learn how your organisation can apply TA-driven leadership strategies, contact us today.

For your EQ and leadership needs, please feel free to reach out to our partners at Circle and Square, Cindy at cindy@circleandsquare.co.za, or Mich at michal@circleandsquare.co.za.

Topics like effective leadership will be on the agenda at our must-attend Annual Employment Conference (#AEC25) on the 19th of March 2025. Join Thembi Chagonda (Employment Equity Commissioner), John Botha (previous Employment Equity Commissioner), Johnny Goldberg (one NEDLAC), Craig Kirchmann (Labour Law Expert), Dr. Mark Bussin, and many more speakers at the conference. Set your organisation up for success in 2025 and register today! (Register here: https://globalretailoutlet.co.za/showeven