B-BBEE and "Substance Over Legal Form"

The concept of “substance over legal form” is a fundamental principle in Broad-Based Black Economic Empowerment (B-BBEE) verification. It emphasizes that the true economic reality and intent of a transaction or initiative should take precedence over its legal or formal structure.

Key Points:

1. Economic Reality vs. Legal Structure:

   • Substance: Focuses on the actual economic impact and the true intent behind a transaction or initiative.

   • Legal Form: Refers to the formal, legal structure of the transaction, which might not always reflect its true economic substance
     

2. B-BBEE Verification:

   • B-BBEE verification agencies assess both the legal form and the substance of transactions to ensure that they genuinely contribute to economic empowerment.

   • The principle is crucial for preventing superficial or “paper-based” initiatives that look good on paper but do not result in meaningful transformation
     

3. Legislation and Codes:

   • The B-BBEE Codes of Good Practice explicitly state that substance should take precedence over legal form when measuring compliance

   • This approach ensures that initiatives genuinely benefit Black people and contribute to sustainable economic empowerment
     

4. Practical Application:

   • When developing or evaluating a B-BBEE strategy, organizations should focus on the real economic benefits and impacts of their initiatives rather than just meeting formal requirements.

   • This means avoiding once-off initiatives that only aim to score points on the B-BBEE scorecard without delivering tangible benefits

In essence, the “substance over legal form” principle ensures that B-BBEE initiatives are genuine and impactful, promoting real economic empowerment rather than just fulfilling formal requirements.

If you have any specific questions or need further details, feel free to ask Richard, richard@globalbusiness.co.za, or Cindie, cindie@globalbusiness.co.za.

Have you registered for our Annual Labour Law Update: https://globalretailoutlet.co.za/showevent/57?utm_source=SM&utm_medium=Event&utm_campaign=AnualLabourLawUpdate2024August2024&utm_id=ALLU24&fbclid=IwY2xjawFH0vRleHRuA2FlbQIxMAABHT_8rWOcbZZlJKogI2DLLNZW9wV4_yTH5_L_yLYEiV1pg8KOgTwkWuW9yA_aem_5bPlCsSX0mA2ndvVp0h7yg